Literary Ales

Thoughts of a Reforming Pelagian

  • Home
  • Links
    • 0
      25 May 2011

      A Review of Mass: The Glory, the Mystery, the Tradition

      • Edit
      • Delete
      • Tags
      • Autopost

      On Pima County Library’s shelf was Mass: The Glory, the Mystery, the Tradition by Cardinal Donald Wuerl and Mike Aquilina. So I thought to borrow it and see how Romans viewed their own mass. The book explains each part of the service, leading up to the Eucharist. However, it does this in a nontechnical way, and really does not support such issues as transubstantiation. I also felt they cherry-picked quotes from church fathers to support why such ornate materials were used in the mass. (Precious metals, gems, and such.)

      Overall, it is not a bad explanation of the service; it is much more useful as a comparison between Roman and Reformed piety and liturgy (assuming you know Reformed piety and liturgy). The book’s purpose is to instruct lay members of the Church of Rome in the essentials of their faith. An advantage of the book is that it is a quick read. 

      While it may be worth the read, get it at your local library; in my opinion it is not worth the price tag.

      • views
      • Tweet
    • 0
      15 May 2010

      What is the Lord’s Supper? A Review

      • Edit
      • Delete
      • Tags
      • Autopost
      Richard D. Philips teaches on the Lord’s Supper in this instalment of P&R’s Basics of the Reformed Faith Series. 
       
      What is the Lord’s Supper? begins with a discussion of why the Eucharist is often neglected in contemporary evangelicalism. He challenges us to restore the Lord’s Supper to a proper place in worship.
       
      To aid in this challenge, Richard Philips first discusses passages from the Bible relating to the Lord’s Supper. Using B.B. Warfield as a guide he discusses the relation of Passover to the Eucharist. The exposition continues as the role of the Lord’s Supper as a sign and seal is discussed. 
       
      Richard Philips gives an overview of views of how Christ is present in the Supper. He briefly discusses transubstantiation, consubstantiation, memorialism, and spiritual presence. I do not think enough space is given to a positive formation of the Reformed (spiritual presence) view, but recongize that is hard to do in a book of this size. 
       
      The next section discusses the efficacy of the sacrament, what grace is conferred and how. Rev. Philips asserts (in line with historic Reformed thought) that the sacrament is necessary for growth in faith, and the Supper strengthens the faith of those who partake rightly.
       
      The final section discusses pastoral concerns: frequency of communion, recipients of communion (with a note on pædocommunion), and worthy partaking. He gives an excellent quote by Jean Calvin: 
      This is the worthiness—the best and only kind we can bring to God—to offer our vileness and our unworthiness to him so that in his mercy we may be taken as worthy; to despair in ourselves so that we may be lifted up by him; to accuse ourselves so that we may be justified by him.
      • views
      • Tweet
    • Search

    • My Other Blogs

      • The Halls of Tucson
      • Reformed Confessions Serialized
    • Blogroll

      • Cavman Considers
      • reformation 21
    • Websites

      • ESV Online
      • BoardGameGeek
      • Reformed Forum
      • Wikipedia
      • Westminster Bookstore
    • Books

      • Biblical Theology — Geerhardus Vos
      • Reformed Dogmatics — Herman Bavinck
      • Institutes of the Christian Religion — John Calvin
      • Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell — Susanna Clarke
      • Planet Narnia — Michael Ward
      • The Lord of the Rings — J.R.R. Tolkien
      • Reformation Study Bible (ESV)
      • Word of God in English: Criteria for Excellence in Bible Translation — Leland Ryken
      • The Valley of Vision — Arthur G. Bennett
    • Children's Books

      • The Jesus Storybook Bible: Every Story Whispers His Name — Sally Lloyd-Jones
      • The Big Picture Story Bible — David Helm
    • Tags

      • John Calvin
      • Basics of the Reformed Faith
      • Carl Trueman
      • Augustine
      • Bible
      • Confessions
      • baptism
      • covenant
      • grace
      • photography
      • Calvin
      • Martin Luther
      • Trinity
      • Tucson
      • justification
      • 16th century
      • Carcassonne
      • Christmas
      • God
      • Institutes of Christian Religion
      • Jesus
      • Philip Graham Ryken
      • Reformed
      • Thomas
      • Tolkien
      • beer
      • creation
      • evangelicalism
      • history
      • worldview
      • zeal
      • Eucharist
      • Lord’s Supper
      • Michael Ward
      • Books
      • Bryan Chapell
      • C. S. Lewis
      • Christian Doctrine
      • Chronicles of Narnia
      • Church
      • Covenant Theology
      • Derek Thomas
      • Dispensationalism
      • Eschatology
      • Family
      • German-style Board Game
      • Glenn Beck
      • Graeme Goldsworthy
      • Heinrich Bullinger
      • Herman Bavinck
      • Incarnation
      • Israel
      • Jaroslav Pelikan
      • Jesus Seminar
      • Johann Tetzel
      • John
      • Kim Riddlebarger
      • Lord of the Rings
      • Luke
      • Macintosh
      • Mark
      • Matthew
      • Nativity
      • Pixar
      • Planet Earth
      • Robert Funk
      • Roy Hoover
      • Scotland
      • Stephen Smallman
      • Ten Commandments
      • The Five Gospels
      • Wages of Spin
      • Westminster Confession of Faith
      • abortion
      • amillennialism
      • atheism
      • backyard
      • church history
      • covenant children
      • death
      • environmentalism
      • faith
      • film review
      • hope
      • humour
      • iMac
      • infant baptism
      • joy
      • knowledge
      • organic
      • paedobaptism
      • piety
      • politics
      • preaching
      • providence
      • quotes
      • racism
      • redemption
      • sacrament
    • Archive

      • 2012 (5)
        • May (3)
        • January (2)
      • 2011 (47)
        • December (1)
        • November (1)
        • October (2)
        • September (3)
        • August (2)
        • June (2)
        • May (12)
        • April (10)
        • March (7)
        • February (4)
        • January (3)
      • 2010 (47)
        • December (4)
        • November (3)
        • September (3)
        • August (3)
        • July (5)
        • June (5)
        • May (5)
        • April (7)
        • March (6)
        • February (2)
        • January (4)
      • 2009 (27)
        • December (1)
        • November (2)
        • October (4)
        • September (3)
        • August (3)
        • July (3)
        • June (1)
        • April (3)
        • March (2)
        • February (2)
        • January (3)
      • 2008 (53)
        • December (6)
        • November (8)
        • October (4)
        • September (2)
        • August (5)
        • July (2)
        • June (2)
        • May (3)
        • April (3)
        • March (5)
        • February (7)
        • January (6)
      • 2007 (18)
        • December (7)
        • November (11)
    • Obox Design
  • Literary Ales

    A twenty-something confessional Presbyterian writing from Tucson, Az.

    14184 Views
  • Get Updates

    Subscribe via RSS
    TwitterFacebookTumblr