Literary Ales

Thoughts of a Reforming Pelagian

  • Home
  • Links
    • 0
      12 Nov 2010

      Calvin on Assurance

      • Edit
      • Delete
      • Tags
      • Autopost
      One of my friends recently listened to a lecture in a Western Civ course about John Calvin. The professor stated that Calvin did not believe Christians could be assured of their salvation. My friend was sceptical and asked me if I knew about this. I replied I was reasonably certain that Calvin did teach assurance, but I’d look it up for him. (After looking it up I now should have been very certain he taught assurance.)

      In The Institutes, Calvin mainly addresses assurance in 3.2. Here are some quotes from that chapter. Brackets are mine except the Scripture references which are Calvin’s editor, John T. McNeill. 

       

      3.2.16:

      No man is a believer, I say, except him who, leaning upon the assurance of his salvation, confidently triumphs over the devil and death; as we are taught from that masterly summation of Paul: I have confessed that “neither death nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor powers, nor things present, nor things to come … [Calvin’s ellipsis] can separate us from the love of God which embraces us in Christ Jesus” [Rom. 8:38–39 p.]. Thus, in the same manner, the apostle does not consider the eyes of our minds well illumined, except as we discern what the hope of the eternal inheritance is to which we have been called [Eph 1:18]. And everywhere he so teaches as to intimate that we cannot otherwise well comprehend the goodness of God unless we gather from it the fruit of great assurance. 

      3.2.24: Calvin teaches the basis of our assurance is union with Christ. 

      For because they [the half-papists] cannot defend that rude doubt which has been handed down in the schools [mediaeval scholasticism], they take refuge in another fiction: that they may make an assurance mingled with unbelief. When ever we look upon Christ, they confess that we find full occasion for good hope in him. But because we are always un-worthy of all those benefits which are offered to us in Christ, they would have us waver and hesitate at the sight of our unworthiness. IN brief, they so set conscience between hope and fear that it alternates from one to the other intermittently and by turns….But what kind of confidence will that be, which now and again yields to despair? If, they say, you contemplate Christ, there is sure salvation: if you turn back to yourself, there is sure damnation. Therefore unbelief and good hope must alternately reign in your mind. As if we ought to think of Christ, standing afar off and not dwelling in us! For we await salvation from him not because he appears afar off, but because he makes us, ingrafted into his body, participants not only in all his benefits but also in himself. So I turn this argument of theirs against them: if you contemplate yourself there is sure damnation. But since Christ has been so imparted to you with all his benefits that all this things are made yours, that you are made a member of him, indeed one with him, his righteousness overwhelms your sins; his salvation wipes out your condemnation; with his worthiness he intercedes that your unworthiness may not come before God’s sight. Surely this is so: We ought not to separate Christ from ourselves or ourselves from him. Rather we ought to hold fast bravely with both hands to that fellowship by which he has bound himself to us. 

      3.2.40:

      Not content with trying to undermine firmness of faith in one way alone, they [the Schoolmen] assail it from another quarter. Thus, they say that even though according to our present state of righteousness we can judge concerning our possession of the grace of God, the knowledge of final perseverance remains in suspense. A fine confidence of salvation is left to us, if by moral conjecture we judge that at the present moment we are in grace, but we know not what will become of us tomorrow!

      These passages definitely teach assurance, not only that it is possible but a vital part of faith! Perhaps this professor needs some of Calvin’s famous spectacles. 


      • views
      • Tweet
    • 0
      9 Sep 2010

      Bones, God, and Faith

      • Edit
      • Delete
      • Tags
      • Autopost
      This dialogue is from the TV Show Bones (Season 5 Episode 13: The Devil in the Details) at the end of the episode. The two character are the FBI Special Agent Seeley Booth who is a Roman Catholic, and Dr Temperance Brennan, ‘Bones’, an atheistic rationalistic forensic anthropologist. 

      Dr Temperance Brennan: I need to ask you some things.
      Special Agent Seeley Booth: You’re going to ask me about God and the Devil.
      Brennan: Yes.
      Booth: You’re going to ask me how God can place such a burden on good people.
      Brennan: No, I was going to ask you how you still believe in a kind God after a case like this.
      Booth: Is my faith shaken? Yeah. Uh-huh, it is.
      Brennan: It is? 
      Booth: Yeah. I’ll go home tonight and I’ll lie in bed. I’ll toss and I’ll turn and I’ll beat myself up; I’ll question everything.
      Brennan: Will you get your faith back?
      Booth: Always have in the past.
      Brennan: So you have faith that you will retain your faith?
      [Booth smiles]
      Brennan: Why?
      Booth: Because, Bones, the sun’ll come up and tomorrow’s a new day.
      Brennan: [Laughs] I know that feeling.
      Booth: Really?
      Brennan: Uh-huh
      Booth: You know what it feels like to get your faith back?
      Brennan: When I see effects and I'm unable to discern the cause, my faith in reason and consequences is shaken. 
      Booth: And then what happens? 
      Brennan: Two plus two equals four; I put sugar in my coffee and it tastes sweet; the sun comes up because the world turns. These things are beautiful to me. There are mysteries I will never understand. But, everywhere I look, I see proof that for every effect, there is a corresponding cause, even if I can't see it. I find that reassuring. 
      Booth: And life is good again. 
      Brennan: [Laughs] Life is very good. 
      Booth: Yes it is
      [Both laugh]

      Now, while Agent Booth’s answer to why he regains his faith leaves something to be desired, it is noteworthy that the writers recognise that even atheists have faith; empiricism cannot be proved empirically. Rationalists have to trust that their senses describe the world as it is, which requires an element of faith. 
      • views
      • Tweet
    • Search

    • My Other Blogs

      • The Halls of Tucson
      • Reformed Confessions Serialized
    • Blogroll

      • Cavman Considers
      • reformation 21
    • Websites

      • ESV Online
      • BoardGameGeek
      • Reformed Forum
      • Wikipedia
      • Westminster Bookstore
    • Books

      • Biblical Theology — Geerhardus Vos
      • Reformed Dogmatics — Herman Bavinck
      • Institutes of the Christian Religion — John Calvin
      • Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell — Susanna Clarke
      • Planet Narnia — Michael Ward
      • The Lord of the Rings — J.R.R. Tolkien
      • Reformation Study Bible (ESV)
      • Word of God in English: Criteria for Excellence in Bible Translation — Leland Ryken
      • The Valley of Vision — Arthur G. Bennett
    • Children's Books

      • The Jesus Storybook Bible: Every Story Whispers His Name — Sally Lloyd-Jones
      • The Big Picture Story Bible — David Helm
    • Tags

      • John Calvin
      • Basics of the Reformed Faith
      • Carl Trueman
      • Augustine
      • Bible
      • Confessions
      • baptism
      • covenant
      • grace
      • photography
      • Calvin
      • Martin Luther
      • Trinity
      • Tucson
      • justification
      • 16th century
      • Carcassonne
      • Christmas
      • God
      • Institutes of Christian Religion
      • Jesus
      • Philip Graham Ryken
      • Reformed
      • Thomas
      • Tolkien
      • beer
      • creation
      • evangelicalism
      • history
      • worldview
      • zeal
      • Eucharist
      • Lord’s Supper
      • Michael Ward
      • transubstantiation
      • Books
      • Bryan Chapell
      • C. S. Lewis
      • Christian Doctrine
      • Chronicles of Narnia
      • Church
      • Covenant Theology
      • Derek Thomas
      • Dispensationalism
      • Eschatology
      • Family
      • German-style Board Game
      • Glenn Beck
      • Graeme Goldsworthy
      • Heinrich Bullinger
      • Herman Bavinck
      • Incarnation
      • Israel
      • Jaroslav Pelikan
      • Jesus Seminar
      • Johann Tetzel
      • John
      • Kim Riddlebarger
      • Lord of the Rings
      • Luke
      • Macintosh
      • Mark
      • Matthew
      • Nativity
      • Pixar
      • Planet Earth
      • Robert Funk
      • Roy Hoover
      • Scotland
      • Stephen Smallman
      • Ten Commandments
      • The Five Gospels
      • Wages of Spin
      • Westminster Confession of Faith
      • abortion
      • amillennialism
      • atheism
      • backyard
      • church history
      • covenant children
      • death
      • environmentalism
      • film review
      • hope
      • humour
      • iMac
      • infant baptism
      • joy
      • knowledge
      • organic
      • paedobaptism
      • piety
      • politics
      • preaching
      • providence
      • quotes
      • racism
      • redemption
      • sacrament
    • Archive

      • 2012 (5)
        • May (3)
        • January (2)
      • 2011 (47)
        • December (1)
        • November (1)
        • October (2)
        • September (3)
        • August (2)
        • June (2)
        • May (12)
        • April (10)
        • March (7)
        • February (4)
        • January (3)
      • 2010 (47)
        • December (4)
        • November (3)
        • September (3)
        • August (3)
        • July (5)
        • June (5)
        • May (5)
        • April (7)
        • March (6)
        • February (2)
        • January (4)
      • 2009 (27)
        • December (1)
        • November (2)
        • October (4)
        • September (3)
        • August (3)
        • July (3)
        • June (1)
        • April (3)
        • March (2)
        • February (2)
        • January (3)
      • 2008 (53)
        • December (6)
        • November (8)
        • October (4)
        • September (2)
        • August (5)
        • July (2)
        • June (2)
        • May (3)
        • April (3)
        • March (5)
        • February (7)
        • January (6)
      • 2007 (18)
        • December (7)
        • November (11)
    • Obox Design
  • Literary Ales

    A twenty-something confessional Presbyterian writing from Tucson, Az.

    14184 Views
  • Get Updates

    Subscribe via RSS
    TwitterFacebookTumblr